Yurt platform on grade versus sunken piers

[Corey]

We expect to start building our 30' foot yurt next spring (very excited about it too). This will be our year round home and the building location is in north central Vermont.

My question is about the piers for the

yurt platform

. We got some basic drawings from the yurt manufacturer we plan on purchasing our yurt from and we have looked at similar plans from other manufacturers. Some go with piers sunk below the frost line and some go with simple concrete blocks on the grade. The plans we have show both options. I called the manufacturer and he seemed to think using blocks on the grade was just fine. This seems a little sketchy to me but the prospect of saving myself a few thousand dollars is tempting.

What are other people's experiences in this area? Thoughts?


Thanks.

[Jafo]

I think your skepticism is warranted. In VT, I would definitely seek piers unless of course you are sitting on granite.

[Corey]

Thanks Jafo. There's some ledge in the area but not a nice slab of it right on the surface. A couple of outbuildings at my current place are just on stacked stone and have been there forever so that gave me some hope that I could get away with not having to sink the piers.

[stephanwik]

We've got lots of granite in Sweden. I simply bolted my platform posts to the rocks using a rock drill and some special shoes that have a piece of rebar welded to them. Drill in 30cm 22mm hole, pop in the shoe and secure with either some large galvanised nails or a bit of cement and Bobs your Uncle.

We've just had two 25 m/s storms and the platforms have not moved at all.

[Bob Rowlands]

Look around the building site that should tell you. If there is evidence of frost heaving where you are siting the yurt, and you want a level platform for the long term, then placing piers below frost level would be a wise option.

If not, then block piers will be fine. Be sure to install rebar pins in the core mud. Definitely fill the cores with mud. Don't skip that step to save a few bucks.

To my way of thinking, yurts are transitory structures. That's one of the beauties of the design. Considering such, I wouldn't go to thousands of extra in expenses, unless the ground heaved every winter. Good luck.

[Corey]

Originally Posted by Bob Rowlands

Look around the building site that should tell you. If there is evidence of frost heaving where you are siting the yurt, and you want a level platform for the long term, then placing piers below frost level would be a wise option.

If not, then block piers will be fine. Be sure to install rebar pins in the core mud. Definitely fill the cores with mud. Don't skip that step to save a few bucks.

@Bob Rowlands: I am not sure what you mean by "core mud"? Is that wet cement?

@stephanwik: Do you remember who manufactured those shoes? Or what product name I could search for?

I guess I never thought about it before but once the ground thaws this spring I could sink a few test holes to see how consistent the ledge depth is.

[Corey]

Originally Posted by Bob Rowlands

If not, then block piers will be fine. Be sure to install rebar pins in the core mud. Definitely fill the cores with mud. Don't skip that step to save a few bucks.

Bob - Sorry for the late follow up; I had meant to ask this earlier along with the mud question: When you refer to filling the cores with mud, what cores are you referring to? The block piers I have seen are solid blocks. By cores do you mean Sonotubes?

Thanks.

[Asheville Yurt Company]

For your consideration, one of the disadvantages to being close to the ground is dampness. You want to be off the ground at least 2 feet, preferably 3, with a ground cover under there to keep the damp from rising. This will help with the humidity issues but it also exposes you to wind issues so generally an elevated platform is enclosed with skirting as well as having the footers. Your call tho.

[ljamies1]

I dug four holes at least four ft. deep and then found the small/ single concrete blocks which have the spacing on the inside for a 4x4 post to fit into. fill each of your holes with the concrete blocks so their inside hole is facing up and you can drop your 4x4 post down into them/ tamp any gaps with paving sand/ now you have four posts facing up and firmly anchored into the ground/ best part is everything is removable. This is my current set up/ going on a year and a half in upstate ny/ no frost shifts yet...

[andrew3d]

Even down South where frost heave isn't a problem, I think piers sunk at least 4 deep is warranted. I believe you have better protection against strong winds and gusts if your foundation isn't going to move.